Posted: Mon Jan 02, 2006 7:27 pm
funny you should question my whereabouts just as I was contemplating a response to this thread.
I was indeed, "on the golf course" for a bit, but it wasn't the country club course you all pictured...it was the "chip 'n putt" course in the retirement community that my parents now live in. That means that each hole is like 100 yards, as opposed to normal courses that are 300-500 yards per hole. So, therefore, there were no republicans that I could tell to fuck off and start a chain reaction of awareness(except my dad, who in the holiday spirit, decided not to talk any politics, although he and my mom did blast the Fox news channel on every television in there house as usual)
What to say about this thread...my first impression is that I am surprised that Tommy has not commented, although I bet he is waiting and building up some ammunition. Or he is refraining because it would take too long to say all of the things he wants to say.
That's a little bit how I feel. This topic has made me think so many things that I am not sure where to start.
I guess the first thing that comes to mind is sadness. I am sad that so many of my generation are so disillusioned by the current administration (and, no doubt, others in our lifetime)that they have completely lost perspective on America. I agree that there are many things wrong with our country, and that the current administration has exacerbated them with short-sighted policies, and a cocksure attitude that turns of many in other places around the world.
The point is, that is not what America is. Sloth, I'm sorry that your experiences led you to believe all of those things that you mentioned about complete predictabilitiy and ignorance. Yes, those people exist, yes, our country and our world would be a better place if the people with true personality spoke up and fought the generalization and standardation that republicans would like to see sweep the land...but many do.
Over the course of my life, I have run into a great many interesting people who do not blindly agree with everything the government feeds us...several of them post here. BUt there are two major problems that I see, and these aren't with the government: one is that these interesting, subversive, educated, intelligent people get so fed up with the things they don't like, that they become incapable of seeing the good. They lose perspective completely, and give up hope. This often leads to the belief that life is better somewhere else, then these people are consumed with leaving, and are unhappy until they have the opportunity to do so. (Sloth, it isn't just you, I have known several people who have done this, so please don't take offense.)
It is very interesting that someone like Martino, who is also an educated, intelligent, well-travelled person did not come to the same conclusions about Americans as Sloth did. Of course, it could be that Sloth spent his whole life in America, but it could also be that loss of perspective that i am talking about.
I'm not saying that life isn't better and that people aren't mroe respected in some european countries than they are in America, I really don't know. But I do know that America is much more than the bible-thumping, closed-minded bigots who dominate the news these days. That's why I wanted to hear Tommy's take on this, because he is someone who doesn't usually agree with many of the doctrinal views of the power elite, but he maintains a perspective about the country he has chosen to live in. It is sad to me when the people who seem to see the good with the bad are not people who were born here, but many of those whose intelligence and views I respect seem only able to see the worst.
I mentioned that there are 2 problems. The second is that so many of those people who can clearly see where America went wrong decide to leave. If this keeps happening, They will ultimately be right, our country will be left in the hands of those who believe that citizens are there to be manipulated, and that it is easier to manipulate them if their education is limited.
I am not putting down the desire to live in other places. I myself would love the opportunity to live in a european country for a while, to gain perspective on their society, and add that experience to who I am as an American. MOre people should do this, not fewer; but in the end we should bring this knowledge back to America, and incorporate it into the country and its' society.
Europeans have always had the understanding that there are people not far away who have similar, yet different lives due to their nationalities and experiences, and I believe that this understanding has led to some of the open mindedness that many disillusioned Americans seek when choosing to live in Europe.
Many Americans blindly believe that our way of life is the only one that is right, and this is undoubtedly wrong. This belief has been fostered by our own isolationism, especially in the middle of America. That needs to change. The best way for that to happen is for those isolated citizens to meet other Americans who are not isolated and who have more worldy experiences and views. Change happens slowly, and only with coaxing, but it can happen.
All of this is to say that I am a proud American, although I am not proud of many things that America stands for at the moment. This is a difficult time, and I hope that we can come through it and regain the world's respect, and perhaps even more importantly, our own self respect.
Yes, middle Americans elected a leader who has dragged us deeper into a pit, and who claims that salvation lies within a Christian faith. But in every major city on both coasts, this leader was not supported. This is evidence that our electoral system has problems, but the heartening fact is that the true power centers of America are not so short sighted and closed minded. Most tourists who visit America don't go to Kansas, or Mississippi; they go to New York, Los Angeles, places where they can see the diversity and vibrancy of life here in America.
I have never lived in another country, so I'm not sure of my next statement, but I conjecture that every place has its' pros and cons, that political ideologies are neither wholly good or wholly bad. Someone mentioned the "grass is always greener" earlier, and I am very wary of this. Nowhere is perfect, and everyplace needs the voices of intelligent, creative citizens to keep the country growing and changing as the world does.
I was indeed, "on the golf course" for a bit, but it wasn't the country club course you all pictured...it was the "chip 'n putt" course in the retirement community that my parents now live in. That means that each hole is like 100 yards, as opposed to normal courses that are 300-500 yards per hole. So, therefore, there were no republicans that I could tell to fuck off and start a chain reaction of awareness(except my dad, who in the holiday spirit, decided not to talk any politics, although he and my mom did blast the Fox news channel on every television in there house as usual)
What to say about this thread...my first impression is that I am surprised that Tommy has not commented, although I bet he is waiting and building up some ammunition. Or he is refraining because it would take too long to say all of the things he wants to say.
That's a little bit how I feel. This topic has made me think so many things that I am not sure where to start.
I guess the first thing that comes to mind is sadness. I am sad that so many of my generation are so disillusioned by the current administration (and, no doubt, others in our lifetime)that they have completely lost perspective on America. I agree that there are many things wrong with our country, and that the current administration has exacerbated them with short-sighted policies, and a cocksure attitude that turns of many in other places around the world.
The point is, that is not what America is. Sloth, I'm sorry that your experiences led you to believe all of those things that you mentioned about complete predictabilitiy and ignorance. Yes, those people exist, yes, our country and our world would be a better place if the people with true personality spoke up and fought the generalization and standardation that republicans would like to see sweep the land...but many do.
Over the course of my life, I have run into a great many interesting people who do not blindly agree with everything the government feeds us...several of them post here. BUt there are two major problems that I see, and these aren't with the government: one is that these interesting, subversive, educated, intelligent people get so fed up with the things they don't like, that they become incapable of seeing the good. They lose perspective completely, and give up hope. This often leads to the belief that life is better somewhere else, then these people are consumed with leaving, and are unhappy until they have the opportunity to do so. (Sloth, it isn't just you, I have known several people who have done this, so please don't take offense.)
It is very interesting that someone like Martino, who is also an educated, intelligent, well-travelled person did not come to the same conclusions about Americans as Sloth did. Of course, it could be that Sloth spent his whole life in America, but it could also be that loss of perspective that i am talking about.
I'm not saying that life isn't better and that people aren't mroe respected in some european countries than they are in America, I really don't know. But I do know that America is much more than the bible-thumping, closed-minded bigots who dominate the news these days. That's why I wanted to hear Tommy's take on this, because he is someone who doesn't usually agree with many of the doctrinal views of the power elite, but he maintains a perspective about the country he has chosen to live in. It is sad to me when the people who seem to see the good with the bad are not people who were born here, but many of those whose intelligence and views I respect seem only able to see the worst.
I mentioned that there are 2 problems. The second is that so many of those people who can clearly see where America went wrong decide to leave. If this keeps happening, They will ultimately be right, our country will be left in the hands of those who believe that citizens are there to be manipulated, and that it is easier to manipulate them if their education is limited.
I am not putting down the desire to live in other places. I myself would love the opportunity to live in a european country for a while, to gain perspective on their society, and add that experience to who I am as an American. MOre people should do this, not fewer; but in the end we should bring this knowledge back to America, and incorporate it into the country and its' society.
Europeans have always had the understanding that there are people not far away who have similar, yet different lives due to their nationalities and experiences, and I believe that this understanding has led to some of the open mindedness that many disillusioned Americans seek when choosing to live in Europe.
Many Americans blindly believe that our way of life is the only one that is right, and this is undoubtedly wrong. This belief has been fostered by our own isolationism, especially in the middle of America. That needs to change. The best way for that to happen is for those isolated citizens to meet other Americans who are not isolated and who have more worldy experiences and views. Change happens slowly, and only with coaxing, but it can happen.
All of this is to say that I am a proud American, although I am not proud of many things that America stands for at the moment. This is a difficult time, and I hope that we can come through it and regain the world's respect, and perhaps even more importantly, our own self respect.
Yes, middle Americans elected a leader who has dragged us deeper into a pit, and who claims that salvation lies within a Christian faith. But in every major city on both coasts, this leader was not supported. This is evidence that our electoral system has problems, but the heartening fact is that the true power centers of America are not so short sighted and closed minded. Most tourists who visit America don't go to Kansas, or Mississippi; they go to New York, Los Angeles, places where they can see the diversity and vibrancy of life here in America.
I have never lived in another country, so I'm not sure of my next statement, but I conjecture that every place has its' pros and cons, that political ideologies are neither wholly good or wholly bad. Someone mentioned the "grass is always greener" earlier, and I am very wary of this. Nowhere is perfect, and everyplace needs the voices of intelligent, creative citizens to keep the country growing and changing as the world does.